Best Must-Try Pizza in West Virginia

1. Pies & Pints in Fayetteville

Pies & Pints has earned its keep, not to mention accolades from all quarters. Notably, these locals' hang is the best pizza in Fayetteville, and the food is a cut above the competition. In addition, Pies & Pints boasts a nifty bar with a few seats. Aside from the food, you can also order from a mobile menu. As a bonus, this quaint little restaurant is just a hop, skip, and jump away from the awe-inspiring New River Gorge National Park. So, if you want to take in the majesty of nature or enjoy a good ole' fashioned whiskey-fueled night out, Pies & Pints is a worthy addition to your list of dining requisites.

2. Pizza & Cream in Nebo

Located in Nebo, West Virginia, Pizza & Cream serves up the best of both worlds. Not only do they have wood-fired pizza, they also have a menu stocked with artisan-style food items and homemade ice cream. They have an awesome patio and a well-stocked bar. Plus, they have a full menu of drinks, including craft beer. The restaurant has a wide variety of specialty pizzas and specialty sodas by the bottle. The menu is a mix of traditional and not-so-traditional, like the New York-style pizza with bacon and cheddar cheese. There is also a selection of gourmet sandwiches to go with the gourmet pies.

3. DiCarlo's Pizza in Wheeling

DiCarlo's Pizza has been a local favorite in Wheeling for decades. The company began in the late 1800s in Steubenville, Ohio. Today, half a dozen pizza shops serve the signature style of pizza. DiCarlo's is a family-run business. Anna DiCarlo runs the corporate stores. Her father is the original owner. She attributes their success to his keen business sense and his kindness. Aside from the pizza, the store also sells handcrafted cakes and donuts. They eventually opened a grocery store. They began selling Italian bread. Later, they converted the grocery store into a bakery. The bakery was a popular spot in the community.

4. Montese's Pizza in Martinsburg

Montese's is a family-friendly restaurant with a lot to offer. They provide a lot more than just pizza. You can also order takeout and pickup. This is perfect for people who have little time to eat. Also, they have outdoor bike racks for cyclists. Aside from the pizza, they also have a buffet with many options. They have a great selection of old-fashioned salads, novelty fares, and colossal pizzas. The buffet is also very well maintained and kept clean. It's worth a visit.

5. Sirianni's Pizza Café in Davis

Sirianni's Pizza Cafe, located in Davis, West Virginia, is a family-run pizza shop. Owned by Michael Goss and his mother, Saundra, the restaurant has been open since 1988. Although the restaurant's popularity has not decreased in recent years, it has faced challenges due to the climate and the lack of staff. However, Goss has high hopes for the future. Sirianni's Pizza Cafe is a local favorite that offers a range of pizzas and Italian bites. The menu also includes a large selection of salads, stuffed peppers, and iced tea. The restaurant is also known for its fine decor and exceptional atmosphere.